Skip to main content

You can absolutely enroll in Medicare on your own. But just because you can do something yourself doesn't always mean you should.

You can change your own oil, file your own taxes, and even cut your own hair.

Now, whether any of those things turn out well is a completely different conversation.

Medicare is a little like that.

You can go online, compare plans, click a few buttons, and enroll yourself. There's nothing wrong with doing that. In fact, Medicare has some helpful resources available to make the process easier.

But here's the question we think is worth asking:

Just because you can enroll yourself, does that mean you're making the best decision for your situation?

Let's talk about what a Medicare agent actually does, what it costs, and why having someone in your corner might be more valuable than you realize.

1. Does It Cost Anything to Work With a Medicare Agent?

Let's start with the question that makes everyone a little suspicious.

"What's this going to cost me?"

It's a fair question. We've all been offered something for free, only to discover that "free" apparently requires a credit card and a 12-month commitment.

Fortunately, Medicare agents work a little differently.

In most cases, you don't pay an agent anything for helping you compare and enroll in Medicare plans.

Instead, insurance companies generally compensate agents when someone enrolls in a plan through them. The compensation is built into the insurance company's distribution costs, rather than being charged to you as a separate fee.

And here's something important: You generally pay the same plan premium whether you enroll directly with the insurance company or through an agent.

So, you're not necessarily saving money by doing everything yourself.

You're just doing more of the work.

Of course, it's still worth asking your agent how they're compensated and which insurance companies they represent.

Which brings us to our next question.

2. Does a Medicare Agent Represent Every Insurance Company?

Not necessarily.

Medicare agents can represent multiple insurance companies, but that doesn't mean every agent represents every company or every plan available in your area.

Some agents work with only one insurance company. Others are independent and work with several.

At Both Hands Financial Group, we work with multiple insurance carriers because we believe clients benefit from having options.

But we also believe in being transparent about the companies and plans we can offer.

After all, if you're shopping for a vehicle, you probably want to know whether the person helping you is comparing several manufacturers or just trying to convince you that a particular minivan is the answer to every problem in your life.

And to be fair, a minivan can solve quite a few problems.

But probably not your Medicare problems.

The important thing is finding an agent who understands your needs and is willing to explain the options and limitations of their recommendations.

3. How Do I Know Which Medicare Plan Is Best for Me?

Here's where things get interesting.

There isn't one Medicare plan that's best for everyone.

Your neighbor might love their Medicare Advantage plan. Your brother might swear by his Medicare Supplement. And your friend from church might tell you about a plan that gives them money toward groceries.

Suddenly, everybody has an opinion.

It's like asking a group of people where to get the best barbecue.

Nobody agrees, but everybody is very confident.

The reality is that choosing Medicare coverage is personal.

A good agent should take the time to understand things like:

  • Which doctors and hospitals you prefer
  • What prescription medications you take
  • How frequently you travel
  • Your monthly budget
  • How comfortable you are with potential out-of-pocket medical expenses
  • Whether you prefer predictable costs or lower monthly premiums
  • Your health needs and expectations for the future

For example, a Medicare Advantage plan might offer lower premiums and additional benefits, but it can also come with provider networks, cost-sharing, and plan rules.

A Medicare Supplement can offer more predictable medical expenses and flexibility in seeing providers who accept Medicare, but it generally comes with a separate monthly premium and requires separate Part D coverage for prescriptions.

Neither approach is automatically better.

The right choice is the one that makes the most sense for your needs, preferences, and financial situation.

And that's where an experienced agent can provide real value.

4. What Happens After You Enroll Me?

Now we're getting to what we believe is one of the most important questions you can ask.

Because enrolling in Medicare is an event.

Living with Medicare is an ongoing experience.

Your medications might change. Your doctor might stop accepting your plan. Your insurance company might adjust benefits next year.

And sooner or later, you're probably going to receive a letter in the mail that looks important, uses approximately 47 abbreviations, and somehow manages to explain absolutely nothing.

That's when having someone to call can be helpful.

At Both Hands Financial Group, our goal isn't simply to help you enroll and then disappear until next October.

We want to build relationships with the people we serve.

That means helping you understand your coverage, answering questions, and assisting you when something changes.

Now, there are certain things an insurance agent can't control. We can't make an insurance company approve every claim, force a doctor to accept a plan, or rewrite Medicare's rules.

Believe us, there are days we'd love to have that kind of authority.

But we can help you understand your options, identify the right people to contact, and work through questions that arise.

The real value of a Medicare agent isn't just knowing which plan to choose. It's having someone who understands your situation when you need guidance.

5. Will My Medicare Agent Review My Coverage Every Year?

They should be willing to help you review it, and this is something we strongly encourage.

Medicare plans can change from year to year.

Premiums can increase. Prescription drug coverage can change. Doctors can leave networks. Benefits that were available one year might look different the next.

And even if your plan doesn't change much, your life might.

Maybe you've started taking a new medication. Maybe you're seeing a new specialist. Maybe you're traveling more or spending part of the year in another state.

A plan that worked wonderfully last year might not be the best fit next year.

That's why we encourage our clients to review their coverage during Medicare's Annual Enrollment Period, which generally runs from October 15 through December 7.

But here's something important.

A review doesn't mean you need to change plans.

Sometimes, after reviewing everything, the best recommendation is to stay exactly where you are.

And that's perfectly fine.

We don't believe changing someone's insurance simply for the sake of making a change is good advice.

If your current coverage still fits your needs, that's a good outcome.

6. What If I Choose the Wrong Medicare Plan?

This is one of the biggest concerns people have, especially when they're first turning 65.

And understandably so.

Medicare has enrollment periods, deadlines, coverage rules, and decisions that can have consequences down the road.

For example, choosing between Medicare Advantage and a Medicare Supplement isn't always as simple as switching back and forth whenever you feel like it.

Depending on your situation and where you live, applying for a Medicare Supplement later may require answering health questions and going through medical underwriting.

There are exceptions and special protections, but those rules can be complicated.

And while Medicare Advantage and prescription drug plans generally have annual opportunities to make changes, that doesn't mean you can switch anything you want at any time.

This is why we believe it's important to understand not only what a plan offers today, but also how your decision could affect your options in the future.

A good Medicare agent should help you think beyond the monthly premium.

Because saving $30 a month doesn't feel quite as exciting if you discover later that you misunderstood something important about your coverage.

7. Why Should I Work With You Instead of Another Medicare Agent?

This might be the most important question of all.

And it's one we think everyone should ask before choosing an agent.

There are plenty of knowledgeable, hardworking Medicare agents out there.

We're not going to tell you we're the only people who can help you make a good decision.

That would be a little ridiculous.

What we will tell you is what we believe matters when choosing someone to work with.

You should feel comfortable asking questions.

You should understand why a particular plan is being recommended.

You should never feel pressured into making a decision.

And you should know what kind of support you can expect after enrollment.

At Both Hands Financial Group, we believe good advice starts with listening.

We want to understand your concerns, explain your options in plain English, and help you make an informed decision.

Sometimes that means enrolling in a new plan.

Sometimes it means keeping what you already have.

And sometimes it means helping you understand something you've been wondering about for years but never had anyone take the time to explain.

We're not interested in making Medicare more complicated than it needs to be.

Medicare does a pretty impressive job of that all by itself.

The Bottom Line: You Can Do Medicare Yourself. But You Don't Have To.

There are plenty of people who research their Medicare options, understand the differences, and enroll themselves successfully.

And that's great.

But there's also something valuable about having an experienced professional help you evaluate your choices, explain the tradeoffs, and provide guidance when questions come up.

Especially when that help generally doesn't cost you anything extra.

Think of it this way.

You can absolutely navigate a new city without GPS.

You might even get where you're going.

But if someone offers to help you avoid traffic, construction, and accidentally ending up three counties away, it's probably worth considering.

Medicare works a little like that.

The goal isn't simply to get enrolled.

The goal is to feel confident about your coverage today and know where to turn when you have questions tomorrow.

And that's the kind of relationship we want to build.


Have Questions About Your Medicare Coverage? Let's Talk.

Whether you're turning 65, considering a change to your existing coverage, or simply wondering whether your current plan still makes sense, we're here to help.

At Both Hands Financial Group, we'll take the time to understand your situation, explain your options, and help you make an informed decision without unnecessary pressure.

You don't have to figure out Medicare alone.

Schedule a Medicare Conversation With Our Team

Both Hands Financial Group is not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program. Plan availability, benefits, costs, and enrollment eligibility vary. Our agents may not offer every plan available in your area. For information on all available Medicare options, visit Medicare.gov or call 1-800-MEDICARE.

Cory Carlton
Post by Cory Carlton
Nov 18, 2026, 11:29:21 AM
CEO, Co-Founder, Investment Advisor Representative Both Hands Financial Group is an independent insurance and financial services firm headquartered in Brentwood, Tennessee, serving clients nationwide. BusinessRate recognized it as a 2026 Top 25 Insurance Agency in Brentwood, based on Google reviews.